Plea Bargains: Deal or No Deal?
Plea Bargains: Deal or No Deal?
If you or someone you know is facing criminal charges, you may have heard the term plea bargain. But what exactly is a plea bargain, and why do they play such a significant role in the Canadian justice system, particularly in Ontario? In this article, we’ll explore how plea bargains work, their benefits and drawbacks, and why they’re encouraged. This will help you make an informed decision if you’re ever presented with one.
Photo by Cytonn Photography
What Is a Plea Bargain?
A plea bargain, also known as a plea agreement, is a deal made between the defense and the prosecution where the accused agrees to plead guilty to certain charges in exchange for a lighter sentence, the dismissal of other charges, or some other form of leniency. In Ontario, as in the rest of Canada, plea bargains are a common practice and often seen as a way to expedite the justice process.
Plea deals can be beneficial to both the Crown (prosecution) and the defendant. For the Crown, it reduces the time and resources needed for a full trial, and for the defendant, it provides a chance for a more lenient sentence than might be imposed after a conviction at trial.
The Legal Framework: How Plea Bargains Are Governed
Plea bargains are not explicitly defined in Canadian law, but they are recognized under the Criminal Code of Canada and governed by the common law. Judges retain discretion to either accept or reject a plea agreement, ensuring that the deal serves the public interest and aligns with the principles of justice.
Under Section 606(1.1) of the Criminal Code, a court may only accept a guilty plea if it is voluntary, informed, and represents a valid admission of guilt. This means that if you're considering a plea deal, the court must ensure that you fully understand the consequences and that you aren’t being coerced into accepting the deal.
In Ontario, the Crown Attorney's Office encourages plea agreements as they help alleviate backlogs in the court system. However, they are always weighed carefully against the need for justice to be served.
Types of Plea Bargains
In Ontario, there are generally three types of plea bargains:
Charge Bargaining: The accused pleads guilty to a lesser charge. For example, a defendant charged with assault causing bodily harm might plead guilty to simple assault to avoid the risk of a more severe sentence.
Sentence Bargaining: The accused pleads guilty in exchange for a lighter sentence or recommendation for a lesser penalty. The prosecution might agree to recommend probation or a shorter jail term to the judge.
Fact Bargaining: This involves an agreement between the defense and prosecution to omit certain facts from the case record to reduce the severity of the sentence.
Each type of bargain comes with its own benefits and risks, which are important to weigh carefully with your lawyer before making any decisions.
The Benefits of a Plea Bargain
Lighter Sentence: One of the biggest advantages of a plea bargain is the possibility of receiving a lighter sentence. By pleading guilty to a lesser charge or having some charges dropped, you might avoid a longer prison term or harsher penalties that could result from a trial conviction. Under Section 718.2(b) of the Criminal Code, the principle of proportionality means sentences should be appropriate to the crime, and plea deals often leverage this to reduce sentences.
Reduced Legal Fees and Court Time: Trials can be lengthy and expensive. By accepting a plea bargain, you can avoid the cost and stress of a trial, including additional legal fees. This is particularly beneficial in complex cases where trials might last for weeks or months.
Avoiding the Uncertainty of a Trial: A trial comes with many unknowns. Even if you believe you have a strong defense, trials can be unpredictable. By accepting a plea bargain, you know exactly what the outcome will be, giving you control over your future. Trials can result in harsher sentences if the verdict is guilty.
Privacy: Trials are public, which means all details of the case are available for public consumption. Pleading guilty early in the process through a plea deal may keep certain facts of the case out of the public eye, as trials can often result in more detailed media coverage.
The Disadvantages of a Plea Bargain
Admission of Guilt: Accepting a plea bargain means you must plead guilty to a crime, which will result in a criminal record. This can have long-term consequences for your future, including employment prospects, travel, and other areas of life. Even if you receive a reduced sentence, a guilty plea is a formal admission of guilt.
No Trial, No Acquittal: One of the downsides of a plea bargain is that it eliminates the possibility of being found not guilty. If you are innocent or believe the prosecution has a weak case, accepting a plea deal means you won’t have the opportunity to fully defend yourself at trial and potentially be acquitted.
Pressure to Accept: Even though plea bargains are voluntary, defendants often feel pressured to accept the deal because of the uncertainty of a trial and the risk of a harsher sentence. It’s essential to discuss the deal thoroughly with your lawyer and make sure you're not making a decision based on fear or stress.
Why Plea Bargains Are Encouraged
Plea bargains are actively encouraged in Ontario and across Canada to help manage the overwhelming number of cases in the criminal justice system. If every case went to trial, the courts would become severely backlogged, and justice would be delayed for many. For this reason, the Crown often views plea bargains as an efficient way to resolve cases without sacrificing fairness.
However, while plea bargains benefit the system, they also benefit you by providing more certainty and often more lenient outcomes than rolling the dice at trial.
When to Consider a Plea Bargain: Key Factors
Strength of the Prosecution's Case: If the evidence against you is overwhelming, your lawyer may advise you that a plea bargain is the best option. The longer you wait to enter a plea, the less likely it is that the Crown will offer a favorable deal.
Your Willingness to Accept Responsibility: Plea deals often come with the requirement that you acknowledge responsibility for the crime. If you're willing to admit guilt in exchange for a reduced sentence, a plea bargain might be worth considering.
Potential Penalties: Look closely at the potential penalties for going to trial. If the risk of a long prison sentence outweighs the benefits of fighting the charges, a plea bargain might be the more strategic option.
Conclusion: Deal or No Deal?
Plea bargains can be a powerful tool for resolving criminal cases in Ontario, but they aren't always the best choice for every situation. The benefits, such as reduced sentences and avoiding the uncertainties of a trial, need to be weighed against the disadvantages, such as the admission of guilt and the permanent impact on your criminal record.
Before accepting any plea deal, it's crucial to consult with an experienced criminal defense lawyer who can help you assess the strength of the case against you and guide you toward the best decision. Ultimately, plea bargains offer a path to a quicker resolution, but the decision to accept should always be made with a clear understanding of the legal consequences.